Jump to content

Recommended Posts

On ‎16‎/‎02‎/‎2018 at 8:15 PM, Irres said:

Ok to clarify only speaking for myself not the org view:  (also mostly just theory)

1) Hunting pirates may sound noble....but where is the profit/cost offset?  Sounds blunt I know, but as any "theoretical" anti-pirate organization, why would I take on the costs of eradicating pirates, if there is no profit to be made or at least good will and offsetting costs?  I mean I am making enemies with a group, and potential friends of that group, that I don't necessarily need to be enemies with.

2) Assuming pirates will be dumb, you have done them a lot of favors.  Never underestimate any opponent, these are not actual pirates with no education or reasoning ability but people much like you and I on the other side.  If you can "out think", they can too.

3) Anti Pirate means we do not take part in pirate activities nor do we condone them in our ranks.  It does not dictate an  org's actions in every scenario because "Pirate"!!

4)  It is much smarter to patrol controllable trade routes, which when paid for by individuals, they may use them.  We secure them, this is a much smaller area than "all of space" or "anywhere in a sector".

  It also allows pirate groups an option.  If they want to take on the large org with a considerable military presence, they can choose to do so and quickly learn their mistake.  Or the easier option, they can prey on those who choose not to pay for and use the secured trade routes, and not get entangled with the large org.  Options are good.

5) This in no way means bounties on pirates that are too overzealous will be ignored, in fact they may be taken up by individual groups who feel the need to do good on any certain day, who may or may not be in the org, but not as an ORG activity.  In short the pirate needs to be effecting our cash flow for an org to get involved officially.

6) That option mentioned in 4, will keep business as usual.  Allow them room to operate, with fixed rules, and everyone is happy.  In fact, if an outsider comes in and decides to "pirate it up" in their sector, you may see pirates turn on pirates to keep the status quo, and not get the Large Military presence involved.


All just my view, but it really seems the smarter way to go.


The alternative, of hunting down all pirates, not only seems ridiculously expensive both from a time and cost perspective, it also seems like it could unite them against the big bad overbearing org.

I think you are right about point 4. It is much smarter to patrol a smaller area. Where we have trade routes or mining operations. It take a little time but most smart pirates will learn not to attack any Imperium ship close to one of them areas, even if that ship is not in the area we are defending. As we could send overwhelming force to deal with them fast.

As for your first point, I do think attacking pirates could have things to offset the cost. For one bounty's, we scan and find out who on the ship and we claim the bounty's on them. You get more money if they are live, but some will still pay even if they die, just not as much. Every little helps. You also have the ships they was flying. You might not be able to keep their ship. But i don't think it be anything stopping other people from the Org coming with their reclaimer and striping it for every UEC they can get out of it. 

But at some point, might be at a start of moving in to a area or when they get overzealous. You might have to go and show them the Org can use overwhelming force if need to guard it assets in a given area. But that also might be going into the next system where they are coming from. A stay out of my area or i come to your area type thing. You don't always have to use overwhelming force, but you need them to know it there if needed and you will use it. And that a big offset to cost you have. 

As for your sixth point. You are right but. I think you have pirates fighting each other over the right to a area. Or just attacking them because they have something they want. Or just griefing each other. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

On the other hand we could of course make sure that most pirates do not touch ships running the imperium flag by putting harsh penalties on pirating one of our vessels :

- instant contract on any pirate dumb enough to mess with us: You mess with us and we will make sure it is not worth it. We will find you and we will kill you. We make it personal each and every time.

- maybe a special imperium branch that is set up for "punishing" pirates that mess with our ships: they hunt down the pirates and recycle their ships ;) 

Regular pirates will not mess with us if they understand that the might of the imperium fleet will come down on their heads if they harm our ships. You always have the ones that will attack us just to mess with us but at least we discourage a large amount of players and hopefully they will attack a ship that is from a smaller org that does not unleash the dogs war on them ;)

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thinking about economics or even revenge is overthinking the problem in my opinion. Making a Kill On Site document for every pirate that bothers you will not be a detriment, in fact most would subscribe for the service.

Pirates, are pvp players. Every last one. They have practiced pvp, they have died thousands of times learning skills. I do not know one who would not love a good furball, or would flinch about dying. 

I feel your best tools people have against piracy are being sneaky and avoidance, and your organisational VOIP.  Imperium is full of very nice people and great pvp players. While they may not want to fly next to your starfarer for 4 hours while you make money, they would love to fight pirates if they knew where they were. Get to know them before you need them, they will enjoy helping you one day. Again, pvp players love some pvp.

I would also like to personally encourage you to practice yourself. I think you might develop respect for adversarial players, and maybe even make some friends with a few. After dying a hundred or so times (kinda going to happen) you may be less worried about getting blown up. You might even have fun.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I doubt getting blown up in a fully loaded Hull E will be fun for most players ;) I also doubt that pirates enjoy losing their ships several times per day, I think the waiting time for replacements will get annoying after the first few losses. I really hope this will not be a game where people don’t mind losing their ship or life several times per hour. If I wanted to play Battlefield in Space I would not have backed SC :lol: Losing your life and/or ship should be annoying and increasingly so if it happens frequently. This is not a respawn timer game where you run for a new hornet after waiting an intolerable 10  seconds and then join the furball again or even worse a game where you chose in the lobby to spawn to any of the many spawn points in the universe or a team spawn beacon (or at least I don’t hope it will be this kind of Star Marine game) . Maybe I am too hard core but I would really prefer a more mature space simulation where peoples lives matter and death is almost as annoying as in real life;) 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

The identification of pirate groups is going to start with non-Imperium ships arriving in our territory in multiple numbers, and presumably in combat oriented ships. Honest traders will be alone and in trading ships. Any large non-identified fleet should be flagged and reported along the chain of command, and if possible, monitored until proper respondents arrive.

In theory, pirates interdicting in our domain should not last long before it is reported and dealt with.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm curious to see what prevailing tactics will exist on the part of the pirates. Will they rely on suicide ganks in higher security space maybe scouts that prevent your escape till the main fleet arrives? And just how long will an industry ship be able to last in a fight, so does backup need to be seconds away or can it be minutes away (standing army vs reserves)?

When it came to eve the group I was in we would run mining without an escort as long as the system was considered clear. Which was done through Intel from surrounding systems that linked to ours. Just so much game design that hasn't been announced, to my knowledge, so the picture isn't yet clear.

So I have two theories of how CIG could shape mining operations:

1.   If mining operations have some tanky-ness.

  • They operate without a physically present escort.
  • But assistance will need to be minutes away to support an escape.

2.   If mining ships are weak or easily taken over, then a fighter fleet presence makes sense.

  • Physically present force to deter.
  • Aligned to home, very jumpy miners that run to port when the deterring force isn't seen as enough.

Also it appears the Orion has a turret so I wouldn't be surprised if a large enough fleet had some kind of herd safety when it came to facing a small group of pirates.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Kryzenshteiner
      i missed out on the Pioneer sale , hopefully someone got a spare one they could part with,  i would like to trade some of my ships or store credit for it 
      ships i can offer are :
      Orion, Carrack, Reclaimer, Khartu-al, Blade, Defender, Eclipse and  some ugraded from different hull, ships  like Origin 600i, prowler, hull b , m-50, 350-r 
    • By RodneyD94

      The Scarlet Order is a company born from war.
      In the year 2544, The United Planets of Earth waged a war against the Tevarin race. 
      During Operation Nemesis and The Battle of Idris IV, casualties climbed into the tens of thousands. Tremendous strain was levied against relief efforts and supply chains. The United Planets of Earth initiated a civilian militia initiative, offering tidy sums of currency to those willing to help in security escorts, supply runs, and medical support.
      A team came together on earth to set out for the battle torn planet Idris IV at the onset of Operation Nemesis. Along the way they bonded, and developed decent working relations.
      On the surface of Idris IV, these civilian men and women were overwhelmed by the devastation. They worked day and night with little to no sleep seeking wounded and dying soldiers and triaging them so that they may live long enough to be transported to a proper medical facility. After a particularly long and laborious day, one of the men heard Sergeant Adam Corr, an infiltration team leader during the operation comment about the amount of soldiers blood was on their clothing and started referring to them as “The Scarlet Order”. The civilian men and women of the “The Scarlet Order” became used to the name, and eventual felt honored by it. To date, the name instills a sense of honor and virtue among its members.
      For the duration of the Tevarin war, The Scarlet Order helped the United Planets of Earth in multiple theaters of battle. They serviced the men and women of all branches of the military.
      With the subjugation of the tevarins and the rise of Ivar Messer, The Scarlet Order was no longer offered contracts by the newly reformed United Empire of Earth government. The order began offering services to a civilian market and roamed the human systems hunting high paying contracts.
      After the fall of the Messers, The Scarlet Order found a perfect base of operations in the dying Tyrol system. They operate out of Haven and Front Row and service high paying clients in the nearby Goss system. While they are still a proud group of highly trained personnel, some of the ethics and sense of honor have faded from the Order. Most members offer escorts to those who wish to pass by the Olympus Pool of Goss, others run medical clinics and farms, while others exploit the riches of the Goss system in other ways.
      Organization Communications
      To join us on our Discord server, Click Here
      House Screech: Head of Industry: Constitutes our industry ships and careers. Career paths include trader, miner, engineer, data runner. Examples of industry division ships:
      Orion Prospector Hull Series Freelancer Crucible House Snow: Head of Science: Constitutes our science ships and careers. Career paths include researcher, explorer, medic. Examples of science division ships:
      Cutlass Red Endeavor Class Carrack Constellation Aquila Anvil Terrapin House Venandi: Head of Security: Constitutes our combat ships and careers. Career paths include combat pilot, soldier, gunnar. Examples of security division ships:
      Cutlass Blue Avenger Series Polaris Constellation Andromeda Aegis Eclipse Out Of Fiction History 
      The Scarlet Order was originally a Star Wars the Old Republic guild. We were originally a pre-release guild with a little over one hundred players. After launch, we achieved multiple server firsts in end game content and flourished to numbers over 200 members. After the game went free to play, we started to loose interest in the game. Leaders stopped recruiting, raid leaders stopped raiding and eventually we all went separate ways.
      The few of us who remained friends, play different games together but not as a part of any group. Until now. The Scarlet Order is being reworked and re branded to fit into the Star Citizen universe. Our initial few members have years of experience running guilds in other games and many of us have years of experience in testing Star Citizen alpha. We have a decent sized fleet for starting out and more than one member in the Evocati Test Flight.
      Our Organization has a strong focus on search and rescue with the bulk of our fleet composed of medical and exploration ships. Our industry and security divisions are maintained to support us in all our endeavors.
      We are looking for new members interested in crew and captain rolls for a wide variety of career paths and accept new and old backers with equal enthusiasm.
      The present goal of our organization is to grow as much as possible.
      We have a growing list of ships in our fleet with more stations to fill than members to fill them. In all our Divisions.
      We hope to see you in game citizens! (Click Icon Below to be redirected!)

    • By Baticles
      Hey you!! Yea, YOU!!
      Want to live it up in the better places of Midgard? 
      Party with giants? Share a drink and remince glorious tales of riding space whales in our mead halls? 
      Look no further! Aesir Industries has you covered... 
      If you're lucky you might even get a glimps of the legendary unicorn who lives in Bifrost! 
      Unicorns may or may not be real - if you have enough mead it doesn't make any difference

      We're a highly active community with members around the world and plenty to do, you're never alone. 
      Always up for doing something, you'll never be bored.
      AESIND provides many services and offers several career paths :
      - Development Division : Exploration/Science/Research
      - Industry Division : Mining/Refining/Salvage/Manufacturing
      - Commerce Division : Business/Finance
      - Logistics Division : Transport/Refuel/Supply
      - Security Division : Fleet Security, Mobile Infantry
      - Intelligence Division : Info Management (storage.processing.transport), [Redacted], ...
      - Support Division : Medical, SAR, Repair
      1. English is our primary language but welcome anyone from around the world
      2. We align ourselves with the laws of the UEE and do not allow piracy 
      3. We are both new player and veteran friendly
      4. We have cookies (maybe)
      Feel free to direct any questions our way or come visit us on Discord - https://discord.gg/BjP8cEq
      If you'd like to join us, simply send in your application here - http://www.guilded.gg/#!AXDRnXZpEp?ref=1ArgxkZ4
      RSI:- https://robertsspaceindustries.com/orgs/AESIND

    • By harridous
      I have an Andromeda and some paypal money I'm willing to trade for an AEGIS Reclaimer with. PM me or add me on discord 
    • By Chenzo
      Accepting all applications apply now! - https://robertsspaceindustries.com/orgs/GLORY2THNR
      We specialize in piracy, smuggling and much more!
      Have any questions? Discord - https://discord.gg/SknvkTd Join Today!